« A Difference of Opinion | Main | Really Weird Super-Heroes »

What is a "Wondernine"?

Occasionally one of my students will go on to explore the shooting sports on their own after taking my course.

This is great so far as I'm concerned, but it can be frustrating. The shooting community, like any hobby, is rather insular. Some common concepts and terms that are peculiar to that hobby can often be used without any need being seen to explain them. That is why I encourage my students to contact me if they have any questions, and it is why I maintain this blog.

The word "wondernine" became popular in the gun magazines back in the 1980's. At the most basic level, it is nothing more than a 9mm handgun with a large capacity magazine.

I have mentioned before that, historically speaking, police officers and others who relied on revolvers for defense would have various strategies to increase their firepower. The most common practice for detectives and off duty officers would be to carry two snub nosed revolvers, one holstered at the belt and the other in an ankle holster.

(Please click on all pictures to see if there is a larger image available.)

2snubbies.jpg

(I got that picture off of The High Road, an online forum where people discuss firearm issues.)

This was a pretty good idea, and it meant that the officer would have 12 shots available before he had to go through the rather slow and involved procedure that is required to reload a revolver.

What would be best so far as increasing the number of available shots is concerned would be to have an autoloader with a bunch of ammo in the magazine. If someone is seriously outnumbered and they shoot their gun dry before the threat is neutralized, then all they would have to do is slap another clip in the gun and keep going.

There actually have been handguns that fit this description for a very long time. My favorite handgun, the Broomhandle Mauser which was introduced in 1896, was originally fed from an internal magazine that held ten rounds. Later models were fitted with detachable box magazines which could hold up to twenty rounds.

c96_poster.jpg

But the large and ungainly Broomhandle was hardly suitable for concealed carry. The world had to wait until famed American gun designer John Moses Browning applied himself to the problem.

What Browning came up with was a handgun that looked to be of rather standard design, but which fed from a box magazine holding thirteen rounds. That means one could have the same firepower as an off duty cop with two revolvers, but it would only take a fraction of the time to reload.

The name of this revolutionary handgun was the Browning Hi Power.

browning.jpg

Browning had sold the design to the Belgian gun firm of FN Herstal in 1927, but they sat on it until 1935. The stocks of arms left over from World War I meant that there was not a market for new designs, but they decided to take a chance when the Belgian army was looking to replace their handguns. What resulted was the most popular military pistol design of the 20th Century.

Keep in mind that this gun was introduced at a time when the majority of the armed forces of the world still used revolvers. Thirteen shots and then one or two second reloads by a trained pistolero. Science fiction had arrived.

The name "Hi Power" is obviously in reference to the number of rounds carried in the magazine, but there wasn't anything particularly powerful about the caliber chosen for the gun. It was the 9mm Parabellum cartridge, which was the standard German military pistol caliber at the time. It soon became a huge hit in Europe, with both military and police forces equipping their men with the revolutionary weapon. Even today, it is not uncommon that you will find a Hi Power in the holster of a cop or MP in a foreign country.

Here in the United States, large caliber handguns were viewed with reverence while smaller calibers were dismissed with contempt. 9mm handguns were pretty much ignored.

This began to change in the 1960's. The incidents of mass civil unrest caused many police officers to realize that they were most often seriously outnumbered during a violent confrontation. Increasing their firepower became a priority, and a fair number of them started to purchase autoloaders as off duty and backup weapons.

The first time I became aware of the Hi Power was when I viewed the movie Serpico, which was released in 1973. The protagonist buys one when he realizes that the corrupt cops he works with might mean to do him harm, and he wants to be able to fend off multiple attackers.

There is a scene in the film where a gun store owner has an interesting rant as Serpico signs the paperwork, obviously horrified by the 13 round capacity of the handgun. I suppose he wasn't as contemptuous of the 9mm round as most of his colleagues were at the time.

There were a few other handguns with large capacity magazines available, but the interest really wasn't there. In Europe the Browning dominated, and in America we tended to stick with the larger calibers as our choice for self defense.

This started to change in the 1980's. That was when Glock first started to market an amazing new handgun design.

glock17.jpg

The Glock Model 17 had a magazine with 17 rounds, four more than the Hi Power. It also was built on a polymer frame, which meant that it was extremely light and not all that uncomfortable to carry concealed. (No handgun is really comfortable to carry hidden away, it is just that some are more annoying than others.) Concerns about reliability and the strength of the gun proved to be unfounded, and it was soon accepted as a major advance in handgun design.

Another thing that helped with the acceptance of wondernines was that the US armed forces adopted one as their standard sidearm in 1985. This was the Beretta 92F, and the decision to switch from a .45 caliber round to the smaller 9mm is still an extremely volatile one even after more than 20 years. This is why most of the writers for gun magazines use the word "wondernine" in a disparaging or insulting way.

92FS.jpg

If you are going to be correct, then a wondernine has to be a handgun that has a magazine capacity of more than 10 rounds while also being chambered for the 9mm Parabellum cartridge. I actually use the term to mean any 9mm with a high capacity magazine even if they hold 10 rounds or less.

Let me give you an example. My choice for a defensive carry arm is a little gun made by Taurus called the PT111.

pt111.jpg

It is extremely small and easy to carry. It holds 10 rounds in the magazine, which isn't any great shakes when compared to the guns that can fire off 13 or 17 round without reloading. But since the gun is about 1/2 the size of those larger cousins, I think it is amazing that the engineers managed to pack that many cartridges into such a small space.

Of course, Taurus also manufactures a version that is chambered for the .45 ACP cartridge that also holds 10 rounds per magazine. But it is rather larger and heavier.

TrackBack

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What is a "Wondernine"?:

» Friday Linkzookery - 23 Mar 2007 from Murdoc Online
The Tank The NRO's new military blog by W. Thomas Smith Jr. and company. Two UK Sailors Killed, One Injured in Arctic Submarine Explosion An oxygen generator aboard HMS Tireless exploded while the nuclear attack boat was under the Arctic ice cap. Offic... [Read More]

Comments (6)

trajectory:

The HiPower is still one of, if not my favorite handgun. If someone would shorten and slim it down I'd stand in line to get it for carry. I personally don't have a problem with carrying 9mm HP ammo for defense.

Kirk Parker:

What cartridge is that broomhandle in the picture chambered for? In the illustration it's clearly necked-down, in a way that 9mm parabellum isn't.

I think that's the 7.63 Tokarev round, actually.

James, was this by any chance in response to my Friday post? Just curious...

James R. Rummel:

James, was this by any chance in response to my Friday post? Just curious...

Actually, I'm answering an ex-student's question.

After graduating from my course, she picked up a few gun magazines the last time she was in the grocery store and started to read them. A few of the terms used by the writers confused her, and she wrote me an Email asking for clarification.

I thought this one was worth a post.

James

Bob:

A. FN actually asked Browning to design a pistol to meet the French pistol trials requirements immediately following WWI, which as I recall specified a 15 round magazine capacity. The resulting pistol FN entered in the French trials probably borrowed the double stack magazine from various WWI submachineguns, and had to be designed around Browning's earlier pistol patents. After Browning died, and the 1911 patents expired, Dieudonne Saive (that's the FN-FAL designer) combined the trials pistol with some of the previously off limits 1911 features to eventually get the GP-35 high power.

B. I've always thought of "wondernine" as indicating service pistol sized guns, of the SIG p226/p228 or Glock G17/19 size.

heywood:

"I think that's the 7.63 Tokarev round, actually."

Close, but no cigar. The Mauser uses 7.63x25mm, or .30 Mauser, which is the same dimension as a Tokarev, but loaded lighter. The Tokarev was designed for Russian SMG's like the PPSH.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Please enter the security code you see here

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on March 17, 2007 9:37 PM.

The previous post in this blog was A Difference of Opinion.

The next post in this blog is Really Weird Super-Heroes.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by Movable Type 3.32
Hosted by LivingDot